About this episode
Discover the terrifying true story of the Axeman of New Orleans, who forced an entire city to play jazz to stay alive.[INTRO]ALEX: Imagine it’s March 19th, 1919. The entire city of New Orleans is absolutely screaming with music. Every professional jazz band is booked, every amateur is banging on a piano, and phonographs are blaring into the streets because a serial killer promised to murder anyone who didn't play jazz that night.JORDAN: Wait, so this wasn't just a party? This was a literal life-or-death concert?ALEX: Exactly. A man known only as the Axeman had the city in a chokehold, and he told the newspapers that he would spare any house where a jazz band was in full swing.JORDAN: That is the most New Orleans way to handle a serial killer I’ve ever heard. But who was this guy, and why was he obsessed with the saxophone?[CHAPTER 1 - Origin]ALEX: To understand the Axeman, you have to look at New Orleans in 1918. It’s a melting pot of jazz, voodoo, and a massive influx of Italian immigrants. Most of these immigrants worked as independent grocers, running little corner shops with their families living in the back.JORDAN: So, small businesses, tight-knit families. Easy targets for a predator?ALEX: Precisely. And the world was already chaotic. World War I was ending, the Spanish Flu was hitting hard, and then, in May of 1918, someone started carving their way into people’s homes.JORDAN: When you say 'carving,' what are we talking about? Breaking windows?ALEX: No, it was much more surgical. The killer’s signature was using a chisel to remove a single wooden panel from the back door. Just enough space for a large man to crawl through silently while the family slept.JORDAN: That’s terrifying. He’s coming into the one place you’re supposed to feel safe.ALEX: And he didn't even bring his own weapons most of the time. He’d find the family’s own axe or kitchen tools and use those instead. It felt personal, ritualistic, and targeted specifically at the Italian-American community.[CHAPTER 2 - Core Story]ALEX: The first confirmed victims were Joseph and Catherine Maggio. Their throats were slashed with a razor first, then their heads were hit with an axe. The scene was so bloody Joseph’s brothers, who lived nearby, found them nearly decapitated.JORDAN: Did they steal anything? Was this a robbery gone wrong?ALEX: That’s the thing—nothing was ever taken. Money was left on the dresser. Jewelry stayed in the boxes. This wasn't about greed; it was about the act itself.JORDAN: So the police are panicking. Do they have any leads or just a pile of bodies?ALEX: They were desperate. At one point, they arrested the Jordanos—a father and son—after a victim named Rosie Cortimiglia accused them while she was delirious with a skull fracture. They were convicted, but a year later, Rosie recanted, saying she’d been pressured by police to blam
