Hungry Hill: The Ghosts of Oniontown | Old Wethersfield Village Cemetery, CT

Hungry Hill: The Ghosts of Oniontown | Old Wethersfield Village Cemetery, CT

18:51 Oct 14, 2025
About this episode
Here's the refined, SEO-optimized episode summary in flowing prose:Join host Kristin as The Grim unlatches the gate to Old Wethersfield Village Cemetery — one of Connecticut's oldest and most haunted burial grounds, where colonial history, witchcraft trials, and restless spirits converge on a hill older than the nation itself.Long before English settlers arrived, this land was Pyquaug, home to the Wongunks people. By 1638, Puritan settlers had chosen Hungry Hill as their burial ground — a rise by the Connecticut River whose name is wrapped in rumor and older spirits. The cemetery tells the full arc of American belief through its stones alone: at the base, stark Puritan skulls and hourglasses preach mortality; higher up, urns and weeping willows soften grief into sentiment; at the crest, Victorian cherubs and verse turn mourning into poetry.Among its most significant residents, Leonard Chester — one of Wethersfield's original ten founders — rests beneath a plain Puritan slab, his stone a deliberate act of remembrance for a colony clinging to survival. Reverend Gershom Bulkeley, military chaplain and author of the witch trial manuscript Will and Doom, lies nearby, his grave radiating the severity of Puritan judgment. Colonel John Chester led troops at Bunker Hill and marched with Washington through Valley Forge, his grave tying this quiet hill to the roar of the Revolution. And a cenotaph for Silas Deane — the diplomat who secretly secured French support and helped win American independence — marks a man betrayed by his own country, stripped of honor, and found dead aboard a ship under deeply suspicious circumstances, his body buried in foreign soil far from home.But Wethersfield's darkest legacy predates Salem by nearly thirty years. Mary Johnson was hanged for witchcraft here in 1648, the first woman executed for witchcraft in New England. Katherine Harrison, a wealthy widow accused in 1669 for the crime of living independently after her husband's death, was convicted and exiled — her property seized, her name destroyed. Though she is not buried on Hungry Hill, her absence haunts it. It is a haunting without a tomb, a silence that hums with injustice.That injustice appears to linger. Visitors to Old Wethersfield Cemetery report phantom voices rising from the oldest stones, sudden cold spots sharp enough to raise the skin, shadowed figures that dissolve when approached, and the sound of heavy footsteps on paths no one else walks. Orbs appear in photographs above certain graves, and the Webb-Deane-Stevens Museum's Witches and Tombstones tours draw visitors into the colonial dark where guides speak of apparitions drifting through the ancient burying ground long after dusk.Wethersfield won't offer Halloween trinkets or staged scares — what it offers is something quieter, older, and far richer. The past here doesn't simply wait. It walks.
Select an episode
0:00 0:00