The Revenge of the Value Investor

The Revenge of the Value Investor

1:04:58 Feb 5, 2026
About this episode
Tech is starting to crack and value is outperforming. Where should you be positioned? On this special episode of In the Money with Amber Kanwar, the show heads to Phoenix, Arizona for a special on-the-road episode with Bill and Cole Smead of Smead Capital Management, the father-son investing team behind $5.5 billion in assets under management. In a wide-ranging and candid conversation, the duo explains why today’s market setup looks increasingly fragile and where disciplined value investors are still finding opportunity. Amber digs into Smead’s eight criteria for stock selection, how insider ownership and capital allocation drive long-term returns, and why years of crowding into passive strategies and the S&P 500 have quietly increased risk. They argue that the forces that powered years of U.S. outperformance — concentration, momentum, and passive flows — now look increasingly vulnerable. From the parallels between today’s AI spending boom and the telecom bubble of the late 1990s to their view that capital-intensive tech could face declining returns, Bill and Cole make the case that history may not repeat — but it certainly rhymes.The discussion also explores why international markets look more compelling than the U.S., how under-owned sectors like financials, healthcare, housing, and commodities could benefit from mean reversion, and why owning unpopular assets — and holding winners longer than feels comfortable — remains central to their approach.In the Mailbag, the Smeads tackle viewer questions and specific stocks across regions and sectors, including European banks Barclays (BARC) and UniCredit (UCG), healthcare giant Merck (MRK), and Canadian energy names Cenovus Energy (CVE) and Tamarack Valley Energy (TVE). They explain why scars from past cycles often create today’s best opportunities — and where investors should still be cautious.In Pro Picks, Bill and Cole share several high-conviction ideas that reflect their current positioning, including regional bank Fifth Third Bancorp (FITB), U.S. healthcare leader UnitedHealth Group (UNH), Canadian oil producer Strathcona Resources (SCR), and Canadian lumber company West Fraser Timber (WFG) — names they believe offer attractive long-term value supported by balance sheets, capital discipline, and structural tailwinds.Timestamps00:00 Show trailer 03:45 intro with father son duo Bill & Cole Smead04:10 U.S. & international exposure08:35 Are we seeing the end of U.S. outperformance?11:10 How has Smead Capital’s view evolved? Have they been bullish up until this spot?15:50 Why they are not as constructive on the S&P 500 17:20 Will 2026 be the year of the value investor? And what tech stocks do they own? 19:50 Are the Magnificent 7 the Nortel of this generation? It’s about Capex21:35 History doesn’t repeat itself but it rhymes 24:20 too many fools are chasing tech stocks, it will all change
Select an episode
0:00 0:00